Barefoot Running in the Winter in Ohio on a Budget
I’ve turned a corner in my barefoot running life. It takes a long time for someone like me to build up mileage under normal circumstances, but barefoot running requires an even slower build up, so when I completely started over with barefoot running last year, I knew it would be a while until I was back to normal-for-me mileage. Then I moved to this neighborhood full of hills and I thought I might die. Then winter came and I thought I might die in a snow bank on a hill with frostbitten feet. But I didn’t! And now I’m back to my normal. And it makes me happy.
From almost the very beginning, it was clear that I wanted the feel of barefoot running, but with some shoe-like things on my feet because I couldn’t get the hang of not pushing off of the balls of my feet in order to minimize friction and avoid blisters. Back in those days (uh, 10 months ago), Vibrams were the recommended minimalist shoes. But I think they’re ugly and, though less expensive than regular running shoes, still more than I wanted to spend. Nowadays they have these minimalist shoes, which look totally rad:
But they’re $160 and it enrages me to spend that much of my clothing budget on a single item, so I’ll probably never buy them. Instead of real minimalist shoes, I bought $10 water shoes from the grocery store. To be honest, one of the reasons I started barefoot running last year was because I needed new running shoes, but I didn’t want to pay for them. I’d heard about barefoot running so I looked into more and gave it a try. I read Born to Run and all of the foot science stuff in there made so much sense to me, unlike most things I read which leave me mostly confused. And then I read some more things. But then I switched to wearing water shoes, so was I still running barefoot? Some of the internet says yes, but I have issues with exactness so I DON’T THINK SO! I’m a minimalist runner, but that phrase isn’t heard on NPR and whatnot so I’m saying “barefoot,” but you all know I really mean “minimalist,” right? In real life I say, “Well, not really barefoot, but almost.” which is too wordy for typing.
After barefooting it for a few months, I put my regular old Asics on just to wear while having a garage sale and I threw my back out. The sciency stuff about barefoot running tells me that that was because the bulky Asics affected my gait so much that my back didn’t know what to do with itself so it tried to commit suicide. So I put those shoes in the Planet Aid box and bought myself some minimalist shoes that I could walk around in and not be embarrassed by (I’m looking at you, Vibrams. Yes, you’re embarrassing. And this is coming from me. Have you seen how I dress? If I think you’re embarrassing, then you have a problem). I believe that minimalist shoes should be cheap, so I bought these:
Lovely, under $40, room for my foot to experience its whole range of motion, no bunion pain, and no back pain. I had already built up the strength in my foot tendons and muscles by being close-to-barefoot at all times all summer, so I didn’t have that part of the curve to deal with. But the amazing lack of bunion pain when wearing real-live shoes caused a happiness to bubble up within me, the likes of which I usually don’t experience unless there is some sort of good food involved. Every single time I bought a new pair of shoes, I’d have bunion pain until my foot wore down that part of the shoe. I thought it was a fact of life. Turns out, I was suffering for no reason! And then I married barefoot running. (I didn’t really because I’m not adding a 2nd husband to my marriage until ALL people can get married to inanimate objects, ideas, or even just other people who happen to be the same sex. Wait, is that the “slippery slope” conservatives talk about? Haha, so dumb.)
When winter came, I knew I had to find a way to get through it without real shoes. I put some SmartWool on, upgraded to $30 water shoes, mostly because it seemed like I needed a little extra weather protection around the bottom of my feet, but also because we had sold our house and I was feeling so spendy! The shoes and socks were perfect if there was no precipitation or melty snow on the road. In other words, that combo was perfect for roughly 4 days of a mid-Ohio winter. Wet feet + cold weather = bullcrap. So I asked the internet to tell me what to wear instead, but the internet forgot that I don’t spend big money on single items that I can’t even wear to fancy places where I never go. It kept telling me to get those awful Vibrams and whatnot. I told the internet to try again and it found Seal Skinz for me. Good internet. Now that it’s allegedly almost spring, I have some things figured out. If it’s cold and wet, I wear my water shoes, SmartWool, and Seal Skinz.
If it’s cold and dry, just the water shoes and SmartWool. If it’s over 40 degrees and dry, it’s warm enough to wear just the water shoes and light socks. And that is so, so lovely. I don’t have to, but I usually choose to wear a light pair of running socks with my water shoes because, without the socks, the smell that grows within the disgusting shell of those shoes is life-threatening. Our house is small. If my running shoes smell bad, the whole house smells bad. Also, I like socks because I usually take the liner out of the bottom of the shoes because it tends to slip around and be weird, and then my feet don’t have to cope with leftover sticky stuff. That has only been an issue with the grocery store shoes, though. The Speedo ones still have their liner and I’ve been wearing them since December.
All of those things, including the walking around shoes, come to less than $100. The only part of my combo that will have to be replaced regularly is the water shoes, and now I know I can go back to the $10 grocery store shoes because the Seal Skinz eliminate my perceived need for more weather protection. I used to spend over $100 on shoes 3 times per year. Because that’s what they told me I needed to do and I am ever so compliant. I’d spend that money and still have bunion pain for weeks until I wore down the state-of-the-art cushioning that made my shoes more expensive. Stupid!
I’m totally going to make a list of all of the good food I can buy with the money I’m saving. And then I’m going to eat my way through Columbus barefoot. The end.
This entry was posted by Abby on March 7, 2011 at 10:38 am, and is filed under I run. Follow any responses to this post through RSS 2.0.You can leave a response or trackback from your own site.
-

-
-

This fascinates me. What about shin splints? I have problems with those if I don’t have good running shoes (I talk about this like I’ve attempted to run in the last, um, 24 months).
[Reply]

Abby Reply:
March 7th, 2011 at 1:20 pmFrom my understanding of the foot science, a major cause of shin splints (and a bunch of other common running injuries) is the way our feet are forced to hit the ground heel-first when we’re wearing typical running shoes. That motion isn’t kind to our bodies. When you’re barefoot, you have to hit the ground with the balls of your feet first, which takes the stress away from your shins, and puts it on your calf muscle and achilles, which were both designed for that kind of stress. If you decide to try it, just remember to read a bunch and start sooooo slowly. Your feet will even get sore in that lactic acid exercise way. That was weird for me, to feel like my feet had been lifting weights.
[Reply]
-

From my understanding of the foot science, a major cause of shin splints (and a bunch of other common running injuries) is the way our feet are forced to hit the ground heel-first when we’re wearing typical running shoes. That motion isn’t kind to our bodies. When you’re barefoot, you have to hit the ground with the balls of your feet first, which takes the stress away from your shins, and puts it on your calf muscle and achilles, which were both designed for that kind of stress. If you decide to try it, just remember to read a bunch and start sooooo slowly. Your feet will even get sore in that lactic acid exercise way. That was weird for me, to feel like my feet had been lifting weights.
[Reply]
-
-

“To be honest, one of the reasons I started barefoot running last year was because I needed new running shoes, but I didn’t want to pay for them. ”
HAHAHA!
Loved reading this, btw ~ very interesting and informative!
[Reply]
-

Hello from a fellow Ohioan who is also re-training herself to barefoot run. Have you tried New Balance? I have a old discontinued pair from the 100 line. Here is there new version: http://www.travelcountry.com/shop/new-balance/minimus-trail-shoe-womens.html?RefId=79&RefType=Affiliate&RefSite=RunRam
This guy has good reviews for barefoot running: http://www.runningandrambling.com/
[Reply]
-

You inspired me to try “minimalist” running shoes only because I’m not as tough as you and would cry if I got a rock embedding in my foot. But, I did pick up a pair of the Nike Free from the Nike outlet in Birch Run for $30. I figured cheap enough for me! But I tried a little tonight and have shin splints now : ( Me thinks I’m still heel striking. It felt a lot better when I tried with no shoes. So it was only a good deal if I wear them, right?!
[Reply]

Abby Reply:
March 22nd, 2011 at 8:07 amYou might still be heel striking. Remember to start off really slowly, like less than a mile at a time in order to build up the (so many) different muscles and tendons that you use without big shoes. And read, read, read a bunch of stuff about form and whatnot. Still, $30 is a bargain worth the gamble.
[Reply]
-

You might still be heel striking. Remember to start off really slowly, like less than a mile at a time in order to build up the (so many) different muscles and tendons that you use without big shoes. And read, read, read a bunch of stuff about form and whatnot. Still, $30 is a bargain worth the gamble.
[Reply]
-
-

I know that the nice weather is almost here, but I was cleaning out my garage last weekend and dug out some of my ww kayaking gear and it got me thinking. There are some great water “socks” out there in the kayaking market. Have you looked into those for cold weather? I have Hydroskin socks which are quite warm, but there is no rubber material on the bottom (but a really good layering option). Also, my hubby has the desperado socks. He says they are pretty warm (and should know, he’s kayaked and swam in some pretty cold water…40ish degrees). Anyways the link to the footwear section of NRS (major kayaking retailer) is http://www.nrsweb.com/shop/product_list.asp?deptid=1166
[Reply]

Abby Reply:
March 22nd, 2011 at 4:05 pmOoooh! A whole new world of experimenting! The women’s Kicker Remix Wetshoe for under $40 might even eliminate the need for that extra layer of waterproof socks. I’ll definitely keep that in mind for next winter.
[Reply]

Jessica Hartman Reply:
March 22nd, 2011 at 5:58 pmI forgot I also have the rodeo sock (which look like they are on clearance for $30). They are a pretty thick neoprene with a rubberized bottom….if it weren’t crappy out right now I’d put them on and give them a test run.
[Reply]
-
-
#16 written by Jessica Hartman 1 year agoWell, seeing I got some test comments sent to my inbox from you, I figured I’d let you know that Merrell makes a barefoot runner now too (pace glove). Just got it for Christmas and am walking around in them to get used to them. Got them from the Merrell outlet in Birch Run and with sales and coupons, paid about $70 for them…and they are cute. Might try a short run in the snow today.
[Reply]
-







I do believe I would have to see some pictures of your water shoe/smartwool combo to believe they are actually not less attractive than vibrams. I agree that vibrams are ugly but can’t picture water shoe/smartwool being less embarrassing. Or maybe you are willing to be embarrassed so long as the footwear is cheap?
Way to go on finding a way of running and shoes that work for you!
[Reply]